Electric Mat vs Hydronic In-Floor Heat for a Bathroom Renovation: When Each Makes Sense in a Canadian Home
A Decision Matrix by Heat Source, Room Size and Renovation Scope, With Operating Costs at Provincial Rates
By
Published: November 21, 2026
Fact-checked · , including Canada Energy Regulator, Natural Resources Canada & Electrical Safety Authority
Credit: Shutterstock
Key Takeaways
•For one bathroom in a house without a boiler, an electric mat or cable is the practical choice: it adds roughly a quarter inch of floor height and needs one small circuit.
•Hydronic makes sense when a boiler or an existing radiant zone is already in the house and the floor is open far enough to absorb a thicker assembly and a mixing device.
•Running cost is not the deciding factor. At October 2026 rates, a bathroom floor costs somewhere between a few dollars and about $65 a month to run on either system.
A warm bathroom floor can be delivered two ways. One is a resistance wire under the tile. The other is warm water in plastic tubing. Both end in the same sensation underfoot, and that is where the similarity stops.
The choice is usually framed as a question of running cost. It is not. In a room this small the monthly difference is a handful of dollars, while the installation difference can be an electrician for half a day versus a heating contractor re-piping part of the mechanical room. The real variables are what the house already has for heat, how far the floor is being opened, and how much height the room can give up.
This piece lays those variables out as a matrix first, then works through each row: assembly thickness, electrical and mechanical requirements, permits and inspections, operating cost by province with the arithmetic shown, and what can be repaired once tile is down. Rates and code editions are dated October 8, 2026.
The decision matrix
Read the matrix across, not down. Each row is a question about the house or the project, and the two right-hand columns show which way that answer pushes.
9 rows · 3 columnsTap a header to sort
Existing heat source
Forced-air furnace, baseboards or a heat pump; no boiler
Boiler with radiators, a combi boiler, or a radiant zone already in the house
Room size and purpose
One bathroom; floor warming with the room's main heat left as is
Bathroom is part of a larger floor being heated, or the floor must be the primary heat
Renovation scope
Tile and underlayment replaced; subfloor stays
Floor open to the joists, or a new slab or topping being poured
Floor height available
Little or none; door, tub and toilet flange stay where they are
A half inch to more than an inch can be absorbed or the subfloor can be lowered
Electrical capacity
Panel has room for one 15 A or 20 A circuit
Panel is full and a service upgrade would otherwise be triggered
Mechanical capacity
Not applicable
Boiler has spare capacity and room for a mixing device, pump or zone valve and manifold
Response and control
Short, scheduled use: mornings and evenings
Steady, continuous heat through the season
Trades and permits
Tile setter plus electrician; one electrical inspection before tile
Heating contractor, often a gas fitter, plus the tile setter
Serviceability
Element is buried; controls are in the wall
Tubing is buried; pump, valves and controls stay accessible
Most single-bathroom projects land in the left column on six or seven rows. That is the pattern behind the common advice, and the matrix shows when the advice stops applying.
Forced air, baseboards or a heat pump only. There is no hot water to borrow. Hydronic would mean adding a heat source, a pump, controls and a manifold to serve perhaps 40 square feet. Electric wins on scope alone.
A boiler with radiators. This is the case that tempts people, and the one with a catch. Radiators and floors do not want the same water. As heating engineer John Siegenthaler puts it in his guide to creating multiple water temperatures in hydronic systems, systems with different emitters "require different water temperatures to be supplied simultaneously." His worked example supplies the floor circuit at about 100°F while the higher-temperature circuit runs at 140°F.
So a bathroom loop cannot simply be teed into the radiator piping. It needs a mixing device to temper the water, its own circulator or zone valve, and its own thermostat. With a conventional, non-condensing boiler, that mixing device also has to keep the water returning to the boiler warm enough to prevent sustained condensation in the flue. None of this is exotic. All of it is labour and parts that a mat does not need.
An existing radiant zone. Now the low-temperature water, the manifold and the controls are already there. Adding a loop, or extending one, is a modest job if the manifold has a spare port and the floor is open. This is hydronic's strongest case.
A combi boiler. A combi can serve a floor loop, but the same questions apply: spare capacity, a low-temperature supply and a place for the manifold. Ask the heating contractor to confirm all three in writing before the tile setter is booked.
Start in the mechanical room, not the bathroom.
Forced air, baseboards or a heat pump only. There is no hot water to borrow. Hydronic would mean adding a heat source, a pump, controls and a manifold to serve perhaps 40 square feet. Electric wins on scope alone.
A boiler with radiators. This is the case that tempts people, and the one with a catch. Radiators and floors do not want the same water. As heating engineer John Siegenthaler puts it in his guide to creating multiple water temperatures in hydronic systems, systems with different emitters "require different water temperatures to be supplied simultaneously." His worked example supplies the floor circuit at about 100°F while the higher-temperature circuit runs at 140°F.
So a bathroom loop cannot simply be teed into the radiator piping. It needs a mixing device to temper the water, its own circulator or zone valve, and its own thermostat. With a conventional, non-condensing boiler, that mixing device also has to keep the water returning to the boiler warm enough to prevent sustained condensation in the flue. None of this is exotic. All of it is labour and parts that a mat does not need.
An existing radiant zone. Now the low-temperature water, the manifold and the controls are already there. Adding a loop, or extending one, is a modest job if the manifold has a spare port and the floor is open. This is hydronic's strongest case.
A combi boiler. A combi can serve a floor loop, but the same questions apply: spare capacity, a low-temperature supply and a place for the manifold. Ask the heating contractor to confirm all three in writing before the tile setter is booked.
Floor warming or primary heat
Two different jobs hide under the same name.
Floor warming takes the chill off tile. The room's main heat, a duct register or a radiator, still does the work of holding air temperature. Primary heat means the floor is the only heat source and has to cover the room's heat loss on the coldest night of the year.
Electric systems are designed chiefly for the first job. Schluter's DITRA-HEAT installation handbook says its system "is intended to warm tile floors and make them more comfortable underfoot but can also contribute to space heating." Other manufacturers say much the same: a mat can be the sole heat source only if its output is enough for the room.
That condition is harder to meet in a bathroom than it looks. The heated area is what remains after the tub, toilet and vanity are subtracted. A room that measures 60 square feet may have 35 square feet of heated floor. On an exterior corner with a window, that may not carry the load in January.
The practical rule: if the existing register or radiator is staying, either system is a comfort upgrade and the simpler one wins. If the renovation removes the room's only heat source, a heat-loss calculation comes before any product choice.
Tile choice matters to how a warm floor feels and performs, and our review of non-slip bathroom flooring options compares surfaces that work over heat.
Two different jobs hide under the same name.
Floor warming takes the chill off tile. The room's main heat, a duct register or a radiator, still does the work of holding air temperature. Primary heat means the floor is the only heat source and has to cover the room's heat loss on the coldest night of the year.
Electric systems are designed chiefly for the first job. Schluter's DITRA-HEAT installation handbook says its system "is intended to warm tile floors and make them more comfortable underfoot but can also contribute to space heating." Other manufacturers say much the same: a mat can be the sole heat source only if its output is enough for the room.
That condition is harder to meet in a bathroom than it looks. The heated area is what remains after the tub, toilet and vanity are subtracted. A room that measures 60 square feet may have 35 square feet of heated floor. On an exterior corner with a window, that may not carry the load in January.
The practical rule: if the existing register or radiator is staying, either system is a comfort upgrade and the simpler one wins. If the renovation removes the room's only heat source, a heat-loss calculation comes before any product choice.
Tile choice matters to how a warm floor feels and performs, and our review of non-slip bathroom flooring options compares surfaces that work over heat.
Floor height: where the two systems part ways
Height is the row most often discovered too late.
Electric assemblies
A mat is thin. Nuheat's mat installation guide describes its mats as "only 1/8" thick" and calls for a minimum quarter-inch layer of modified thinset over them. Loose cable set into an uncoupling membrane lands in the same range: the membrane that holds the cable is about a quarter inch thick, or five-sixteenths with a built-in thermal break.
In round numbers, electric heat adds a quarter to three-eighths of an inch beneath the tile.
Hydronic assemblies
Water needs tubing, and tubing needs depth. There are three common routes over a wood subfloor:
Grooved panels on top of the subfloor. Uponor's Quik Trak panels are half-inch plywood with an aluminum heat-transfer sheet, made for 5/16-inch tubing in retrofit work. Add a tile underlayment on top.
A poured topping. The manufacturer's handbook calls for at least three-quarters of an inch of cover over the top of the piping, which puts the pour well over an inch.
Tubing below the subfloor, between the joists. No height is added, but the ceiling below must be open and the joist bays insulated.
What the extra height touches
The door threshold. A half inch is a transition strip. An inch and a half is a step.
The toilet flange. It has to finish at the new floor level, which means an extension or a reset.
The tub or shower base. A raised floor shortens the apparent height of a tub apron and changes how a curbless entry drains.
The vanity and baseboards. Both get shorter by whatever the floor gains.
Curbless showers are especially sensitive to floor build-up; the trade-offs are covered in our guide to tub-to-shower conversions in Canada.
Height is the row most often discovered too late.
Electric assemblies
A mat is thin. Nuheat's mat installation guide describes its mats as "only 1/8" thick" and calls for a minimum quarter-inch layer of modified thinset over them. Loose cable set into an uncoupling membrane lands in the same range: the membrane that holds the cable is about a quarter inch thick, or five-sixteenths with a built-in thermal break.
In round numbers, electric heat adds a quarter to three-eighths of an inch beneath the tile.
Hydronic assemblies
Water needs tubing, and tubing needs depth. There are three common routes over a wood subfloor:
Grooved panels on top of the subfloor. Uponor's Quik Trak panels are half-inch plywood with an aluminum heat-transfer sheet, made for 5/16-inch tubing in retrofit work. Add a tile underlayment on top.
A poured topping. The manufacturer's handbook calls for at least three-quarters of an inch of cover over the top of the piping, which puts the pour well over an inch.
Tubing below the subfloor, between the joists. No height is added, but the ceiling below must be open and the joist bays insulated.
What the extra height touches
The door threshold. A half inch is a transition strip. An inch and a half is a step.
The toilet flange. It has to finish at the new floor level, which means an extension or a reset.
The tub or shower base. A raised floor shortens the apparent height of a tub apron and changes how a curbless entry drains.
The vanity and baseboards. Both get shorter by whatever the floor gains.
Curbless showers are especially sensitive to floor build-up; the trade-offs are covered in our guide to tub-to-shower conversions in Canada.
What the electrical side requires
The load is small. At 12 watts per square foot, 35 square feet of mat draws 420 watts, about 3.5 amps at 120 volts. Eighty square feet draws 960 watts, about 8 amps. A floor-heating thermostat is typically limited to 15 amps, which one manufacturer translates to 150 square feet at 120 volts. A bathroom is nowhere near that ceiling.
What the product instructions and the Code require around that small load is more specific:
A dedicated circuit. Manufacturers call for it or recommend it. That means one free space in the panel.
Ground-fault protection. Manufacturers require a Class A device, usually built into the thermostat.
A floor sensor. It limits floor temperature. Without it the thermostat has no idea how hot the tile is.
A certified, unmodified heating set. Mats and cables cannot be cut or shortened to fit. They are ordered to the heated area.
Resistance tests before, during and after installation, recorded, to keep the warranty valid.
The Canadian Electrical Code treats floor heating under Section 62. A published road map to Section 62 of the 26th edition summarizes Rule 62-116 as requiring ground-fault protection for heating cable sets and panel sets, and describes it as "equipment protection against fire hazards and not for shock hazards." That is a separate layer from the Class A device the manufacturers specify. The same section lets a dwelling group two or more heating sets on one branch circuit rated up to 30 amps, and requires a line-voltage control to open all ungrounded conductors when switched off.
Which edition applies depends on the province. According to Electro-Federation Canada's adoption table, British Columbia adopted the 2024 edition in March 2025, Alberta and Nova Scotia in April 2025, Ontario in May 2025, Saskatchewan in June 2025, Manitoba in March 2026 and New Brunswick in July 2026. Quebec adopted the 2021 edition in September 2026. Each province adds its own amendments, so rule numbers should be confirmed locally.
The load is small. At 12 watts per square foot, 35 square feet of mat draws 420 watts, about 3.5 amps at 120 volts. Eighty square feet draws 960 watts, about 8 amps. A floor-heating thermostat is typically limited to 15 amps, which one manufacturer translates to 150 square feet at 120 volts. A bathroom is nowhere near that ceiling.
What the product instructions and the Code require around that small load is more specific:
A dedicated circuit. Manufacturers call for it or recommend it. That means one free space in the panel.
Ground-fault protection. Manufacturers require a Class A device, usually built into the thermostat.
A floor sensor. It limits floor temperature. Without it the thermostat has no idea how hot the tile is.
A certified, unmodified heating set. Mats and cables cannot be cut or shortened to fit. They are ordered to the heated area.
Resistance tests before, during and after installation, recorded, to keep the warranty valid.
The Canadian Electrical Code treats floor heating under Section 62. A published road map to Section 62 of the 26th edition summarizes Rule 62-116 as requiring ground-fault protection for heating cable sets and panel sets, and describes it as "equipment protection against fire hazards and not for shock hazards." That is a separate layer from the Class A device the manufacturers specify. The same section lets a dwelling group two or more heating sets on one branch circuit rated up to 30 amps, and requires a line-voltage control to open all ungrounded conductors when switched off.
Which edition applies depends on the province. According to Electro-Federation Canada's adoption table, British Columbia adopted the 2024 edition in March 2025, Alberta and Nova Scotia in April 2025, Ontario in May 2025, Saskatchewan in June 2025, Manitoba in March 2026 and New Brunswick in July 2026. Quebec adopted the 2021 edition in September 2026. Each province adds its own amendments, so rule numbers should be confirmed locally.
Important
Because the heating set cannot be cut, the layout has to be final before it is ordered. Fix the positions of the vanity, toilet and tub first, then measure the open floor that remains.
What the hydronic side requires
A hydronic bathroom floor is a small piece of a heating system, and it inherits that system's requirements.
A low-temperature supply. Covered above: a mixing device, plus a circulator or zone valve and a thermostat for the new zone.
Spare boiler capacity. Usually not a constraint for one bathroom, but it should be confirmed, not assumed.
A manifold location. Supply and return for each loop terminate at an accessible manifold, normally in the mechanical room or a nearby closet.
Suitable tubing. Oxygen-barrier PEX is used wherever the system contains iron or steel components, which describes most boiler systems.
Surface-temperature limits. Uponor's radiant floor installation handbook sets a ceiling of 87.5°F (30.8°C) for tile and linoleum surfaces and recommends no more than 80°F (26.7°C) under wood flooring unless the flooring maker allows more.
A pressure test before cover. The same handbook calls for a test at a minimum of 60 psi, held at least overnight, before the tubing is buried.
The finish limits apply to electric floors too. Under engineered wood, vinyl or laminate, thermostat set points are capped lower than under tile. Tile and stone remain the natural finishes over either system.
One sequencing point follows from the list. The tubing, the pressure test and the tile setter's start date are a chain. If the heating contractor is not on site the day the subfloor is ready, the bathroom waits.
A hydronic bathroom floor is a small piece of a heating system, and it inherits that system's requirements.
A low-temperature supply. Covered above: a mixing device, plus a circulator or zone valve and a thermostat for the new zone.
Spare boiler capacity. Usually not a constraint for one bathroom, but it should be confirmed, not assumed.
A manifold location. Supply and return for each loop terminate at an accessible manifold, normally in the mechanical room or a nearby closet.
Suitable tubing. Oxygen-barrier PEX is used wherever the system contains iron or steel components, which describes most boiler systems.
Surface-temperature limits. Uponor's radiant floor installation handbook sets a ceiling of 87.5°F (30.8°C) for tile and linoleum surfaces and recommends no more than 80°F (26.7°C) under wood flooring unless the flooring maker allows more.
A pressure test before cover. The same handbook calls for a test at a minimum of 60 psi, held at least overnight, before the tubing is buried.
The finish limits apply to electric floors too. Under engineered wood, vinyl or laminate, thermostat set points are capped lower than under tile. Tile and stone remain the natural finishes over either system.
One sequencing point follows from the list. The tubing, the pressure test and the tile setter's start date are a chain. If the heating contractor is not on site the day the subfloor is ready, the bathroom waits.
Permits, trades and the inspection before tile
Both systems are regulated work. The rules differ by province, and the authority is often not the municipal building department.
Electric
Ontario is explicit. The Electrical Safety Authority's flash notice on in-floor heating installations states that a notification of work must be filed and that "inspection must be completed prior to the covering of the heating cables/pads." The same notice allows anyone, including the tile setter, to lay the heating portion up to the first junction box. The branch circuit from the panel must be run by a Licensed Electrical Contractor; a homeowner may do it, though the authority does not recommend it. All equipment must bear a recognized Canadian approval mark.
That notice exists because of a death. A man fell on a heated bathroom floor and suffered second- and third-degree burns. Investigators found the floor sensor had never been installed and a 120-volt mat had been connected to 240 volts. The floor reached 62.2°C. No notification of work had been filed. A missing sensor and a voltage mismatch are both things an inspection catches.
Hydronic
A hydronic loop that connects to a gas boiler brings the fuel regulator into the project. In Ontario, the Technical Standards and Safety Authority states that Registered Fuels Contractors "are the only businesses that are legally authorized to do fuels related work." Piping on the water side may also need a plumbing or mechanical permit from the municipality.
British Columbia
Technical Safety BC issues both electrical and gas permits. Its homeowner gas permit rules list boiler installation or replacement among the work that needs a permit, and bar owners of a strata unit, a non-strata duplex or a home with a business from taking out homeowner permits at all. Those owners must hire a licensed contractor for either system.
Elsewhere
Other provinces follow the same shape under different names: an electrical permit and an inspection before the element is covered, and a gas permit where the boiler is touched. Ask each trade which permit they are pulling and which inspection happens before tile.
Both systems are regulated work. The rules differ by province, and the authority is often not the municipal building department.
Electric
Ontario is explicit. The Electrical Safety Authority's flash notice on in-floor heating installations states that a notification of work must be filed and that "inspection must be completed prior to the covering of the heating cables/pads." The same notice allows anyone, including the tile setter, to lay the heating portion up to the first junction box. The branch circuit from the panel must be run by a Licensed Electrical Contractor; a homeowner may do it, though the authority does not recommend it. All equipment must bear a recognized Canadian approval mark.
That notice exists because of a death. A man fell on a heated bathroom floor and suffered second- and third-degree burns. Investigators found the floor sensor had never been installed and a 120-volt mat had been connected to 240 volts. The floor reached 62.2°C. No notification of work had been filed. A missing sensor and a voltage mismatch are both things an inspection catches.
Hydronic
A hydronic loop that connects to a gas boiler brings the fuel regulator into the project. In Ontario, the Technical Standards and Safety Authority states that Registered Fuels Contractors "are the only businesses that are legally authorized to do fuels related work." Piping on the water side may also need a plumbing or mechanical permit from the municipality.
British Columbia
Technical Safety BC issues both electrical and gas permits. Its homeowner gas permit rules list boiler installation or replacement among the work that needs a permit, and bar owners of a strata unit, a non-strata duplex or a home with a business from taking out homeowner permits at all. Those owners must hire a licensed contractor for either system.
Elsewhere
Other provinces follow the same shape under different names: an electrical permit and an inspection before the element is covered, and a gas permit where the boiler is touched. Ask each trade which permit they are pulling and which inspection happens before tile.
Electric. Heated area × 12 W per square foot × hours scheduled per day × a 50% duty cycle × 30 days × the provincial energy rate. The duty cycle reflects that a thermostat with a floor sensor cycles the element on and off once the floor is at temperature. Half is an assumption, not a measurement; a floor over an unheated space will run higher.
Hydronic. The same delivered heat, converted to gigajoules, divided by 90% boiler efficiency, priced at the provincial variable gas rate. The Canada Energy Regulator's energy conversion tables give 1 kWh as 3.6 megajoules and a cubic metre of natural gas as 0.0373 gigajoules.
The 90% figure is the federal minimum for new equipment. Under Natural Resources Canada's efficiency rules for household gas boilers, hot-water boilers manufactured on or after July 1, 2023 must reach at least that level. An older boiler will be lower, and its gas cost proportionally higher.
Two rooms, two schedules. A small bathroom with 35 square feet of heated floor and a large one with 80. A scheduled case of six hours a day and a continuous case of 24. Each cell below is the range from the scheduled case to the continuous case, per 30-day month of the heating season.
One worked line. 35 sq ft × 12 W = 420 W. Over six hours at a 50% duty cycle for 30 days, that is 37.8 kWh. In Nova Scotia, 37.8 × $0.19128 = $7.23. The same heat is 0.136 GJ; divided by 0.90 it is 0.151 GJ of gas, which at Ontario's variable rate of about $7.58 per GJ is $1.15.
10 rows · 6 columnsTap a header to sort
British Columbia
14.08 (Step 2)
$5 to $21
$12 to $49
$2 to $8
$4 to $17
Alberta
12.02 (energy only)
$5 to $18
$10 to $42
$1 to $2
$1 to $5
Saskatchewan
15.476
$6 to $23
$13 to $53
$1 to $4
$2 to $9
Manitoba
9.970
$4 to $15
$9 to $34
$1 to $4
$2 to $8
Ontario
12.3 to 12.7 (Time-of-Use blend)
$5 to $19
$11 to $44
$1 to $5
$3 to $10
Quebec
11.142 (second tier)
$4 to $17
$10 to $39
not modelled
not modelled
New Brunswick
15.84
$6 to $24
$14 to $55
not modelled
not modelled
Nova Scotia
19.128
$7 to $29
$17 to $66
not modelled
not modelled
Prince Edward Island
17.84 (first block)
$7 to $27
$15 to $62
not modelled
not modelled
Newfoundland (island)
15.587
$6 to $24
$13 to $54
not modelled
not modelled
Rates are the energy charges posted by each utility or regulator as of October 8, 2026, before taxes and fixed monthly charges.
Notes on the inputs:
Ontario uses the Time-of-Use prices the Ontario Energy Board set on November 1, 2025. Its electricity rates page lists off-peak at 9.8¢, mid-peak at 15.7¢ and on-peak at 20.3¢. The scheduled case assumes 6 to 9 a.m. and 8 to 11 p.m., which puts two weekday hours on-peak. New prices take effect November 1, 2026.
Alberta and Ontario electricity figures exclude delivery charges, which are billed separately and vary by distributor.
British Columbia uses the higher step, on the reasoning that floor heat is added on top of existing winter use.
Gas rates are variable charges only: commodity plus per-unit delivery and transportation. They work out to roughly $12.60 per GJ in British Columbia, $3.80 in Alberta, $6.40 in Saskatchewan, $6.00 in Manitoba and $7.60 in the Enbridge Gas zone of Ontario. Saskatchewan's posted residential schedule carries an effective date of October 1, 2023.
Not modelled means no residential gas rate was verified for that province. An electric boiler would cost about the same to run as a mat, plus pump energy.
Left out of the hydronic column: the electricity the circulator uses, and standby losses in the piping.
What the table says is narrower than it looks. Gas-fired water is cheaper per unit of heat in every province where both fuels were priced. In a bathroom, that advantage is worth a few dollars to a few tens of dollars a month in the heating season. The table describes running cost only. It says nothing about what either system costs to install, and installed cost depends on the rows above: how much of the floor is open, how far the panel or the boiler is from the bathroom, and how many trades are involved.
Here is the model, with every assumption stated.
Electric. Heated area × 12 W per square foot × hours scheduled per day × a 50% duty cycle × 30 days × the provincial energy rate. The duty cycle reflects that a thermostat with a floor sensor cycles the element on and off once the floor is at temperature. Half is an assumption, not a measurement; a floor over an unheated space will run higher.
Hydronic. The same delivered heat, converted to gigajoules, divided by 90% boiler efficiency, priced at the provincial variable gas rate. The Canada Energy Regulator's energy conversion tables give 1 kWh as 3.6 megajoules and a cubic metre of natural gas as 0.0373 gigajoules.
The 90% figure is the federal minimum for new equipment. Under Natural Resources Canada's efficiency rules for household gas boilers, hot-water boilers manufactured on or after July 1, 2023 must reach at least that level. An older boiler will be lower, and its gas cost proportionally higher.
Two rooms, two schedules. A small bathroom with 35 square feet of heated floor and a large one with 80. A scheduled case of six hours a day and a continuous case of 24. Each cell below is the range from the scheduled case to the continuous case, per 30-day month of the heating season.
One worked line. 35 sq ft × 12 W = 420 W. Over six hours at a 50% duty cycle for 30 days, that is 37.8 kWh. In Nova Scotia, 37.8 × $0.19128 = $7.23. The same heat is 0.136 GJ; divided by 0.90 it is 0.151 GJ of gas, which at Ontario's variable rate of about $7.58 per GJ is $1.15.
10 rows · 6 columnsTap a header to sort
British Columbia
14.08 (Step 2)
$5 to $21
$12 to $49
$2 to $8
$4 to $17
Alberta
12.02 (energy only)
$5 to $18
$10 to $42
$1 to $2
$1 to $5
Saskatchewan
15.476
$6 to $23
$13 to $53
$1 to $4
$2 to $9
Manitoba
9.970
$4 to $15
$9 to $34
$1 to $4
$2 to $8
Ontario
12.3 to 12.7 (Time-of-Use blend)
$5 to $19
$11 to $44
$1 to $5
$3 to $10
Quebec
11.142 (second tier)
$4 to $17
$10 to $39
not modelled
not modelled
New Brunswick
15.84
$6 to $24
$14 to $55
not modelled
not modelled
Nova Scotia
19.128
$7 to $29
$17 to $66
not modelled
not modelled
Prince Edward Island
17.84 (first block)
$7 to $27
$15 to $62
not modelled
not modelled
Newfoundland (island)
15.587
$6 to $24
$13 to $54
not modelled
not modelled
Rates are the energy charges posted by each utility or regulator as of October 8, 2026, before taxes and fixed monthly charges.
Notes on the inputs:
Ontario uses the Time-of-Use prices the Ontario Energy Board set on November 1, 2025. Its electricity rates page lists off-peak at 9.8¢, mid-peak at 15.7¢ and on-peak at 20.3¢. The scheduled case assumes 6 to 9 a.m. and 8 to 11 p.m., which puts two weekday hours on-peak. New prices take effect November 1, 2026.
Alberta and Ontario electricity figures exclude delivery charges, which are billed separately and vary by distributor.
British Columbia uses the higher step, on the reasoning that floor heat is added on top of existing winter use.
Gas rates are variable charges only: commodity plus per-unit delivery and transportation. They work out to roughly $12.60 per GJ in British Columbia, $3.80 in Alberta, $6.40 in Saskatchewan, $6.00 in Manitoba and $7.60 in the Enbridge Gas zone of Ontario. Saskatchewan's posted residential schedule carries an effective date of October 1, 2023.
Not modelled means no residential gas rate was verified for that province. An electric boiler would cost about the same to run as a mat, plus pump energy.
Left out of the hydronic column: the electricity the circulator uses, and standby losses in the piping.
What the table says is narrower than it looks. Gas-fired water is cheaper per unit of heat in every province where both fuels were priced. In a bathroom, that advantage is worth a few dollars to a few tens of dollars a month in the heating season. The table describes running cost only. It says nothing about what either system costs to install, and installed cost depends on the rows above: how much of the floor is open, how far the panel or the boiler is from the bathroom, and how many trades are involved.
Response time and control
Both systems are run by a thermostat that reads a sensor in the floor. The difference is how quickly the floor answers.
A thin electric assembly over a wood subfloor has little mass. It warms and cools on a schedule, which is why the morning-and-evening pattern suits it. A hydronic loop in a poured topping has a great deal of mass. It is slow to warm and slow to cool, and it works best held at a steady temperature all season.
The substrate matters for electric floors as well. Over a concrete slab, an element takes noticeably longer to bring tile to temperature than it does over plywood, and an uninsulated slab may never get there. A thermal break under the element is the fix.
Deep setbacks pay off with low-mass systems and fight against high-mass ones. The same principle applies to whole-house heating, as our piece on thermostat setback mistakes in a Canadian winter explains.
What can be repaired once tile is down
Both systems bury their working parts. They differ in what stays reachable.
Electric. The thermostat and sensor leads are accessible at the wall, which is one reason manufacturers supply or recommend a spare sensor in the floor. The element is not accessible. Nuheat's customer FAQ says the heating wire "can be repaired in most cases" once the break is located, using a repair kit installed by an electrician. In practice that means finding the fault and lifting tile at that spot.
Hydronic. The parts that wear, the pump, mixing valve, zone valve and controls, sit in the mechanical room. The tubing in the floor has no moving parts and no joints if the loop was run as one continuous length.
Installers describe the same few failure causes for both: a trowel edge or a dropped tool nicking a cable or tube during tiling, a fastener driven through the floor later, and a skipped test that would have caught either. Three records are worth keeping for the life of the floor: photographs of the layout before cover, the resistance or pressure test results, and the inspection certificate.
When each makes sense
An electric mat or cable makes sense when:
The house is heated by a furnace, baseboards or a heat pump, with no boiler.
The project is one bathroom and the subfloor is staying.
Floor height is fixed by an existing door, tub or flange.
The floor will run on a schedule, not around the clock.
The panel has one space to give.
Hydronic makes sense when:
A boiler or an existing radiant zone is already in the house, with spare capacity and a manifold within reach.
The bathroom is part of a larger area being heated, such as a basement or an addition.
The floor is open to the joists or a new topping is being poured anyway.
The floor has to be the room's primary heat and will run steadily.
The electrical service is at its limit.
Mixed cases. A house with a boiler and a single upstairs bathroom over a finished ceiling usually still goes electric, because the scope of opening the ceiling or raising the floor outweighs the fuel advantage. A basement bathroom going in beside a new radiant slab goes hydronic for the opposite reason.
Ryan is the founder of Homeowner.ca and a proud Canadian homeowner based in Guelph, Ontario. Over his 25-year career in digital publishing, he has focused on transforming complex information into clear, practical guidance that helps people make confident, well-informed decisions.
In Ontario, yes, up to the first junction box. The branch circuit from the panel is a separate job for a Licensed Electrical Contractor, and the installation must be inspected before the mat is covered. Other provinces set their own rules, so confirm with the local electrical authority.
Manufacturers call for or recommend a dedicated circuit. The load is small, a few amps for a typical bathroom, but it should not share a circuit with receptacles or lighting.
It cannot be cut or shortened. Mats and cables are factory-built to a fixed resistance, and altering them voids the certification. The correct size is ordered to the open floor area after fixtures are placed.
Often, with a lower temperature limit than tile. Check both the heating manufacturer's instructions and the flooring maker's rating; some products cap the thermostat set point at 28°C under these finishes.
Follow the manufacturer's instructions. Ontario's electrical regulator cautions that objects which significantly restrict air flow over a heated floor should not be left on it unattended unless the manufacturer permits it.
Some systems are designed that way, but it is a specialized installation with its own code requirements for separating heating water from drinking water. It should be designed and installed by a qualified heating contractor and permitted locally.
It changes the bill, not the decision. Scheduling the floor for off-peak hours lowers cost, and the Ontario figures in the table already assume two on-peak hours on weekday mornings.
Ontario resets electricity prices each November 1 and gas supply rates quarterly. Several other provinces adjust on January 1 or April 1. Re-check the utility's posted rate before relying on a monthly figure.
Schluter Systems. (2025). Schluter-DITRA-HEAT installation handbook. Retrieved from https://assets.schluter.com/
Siegenthaler, J. (2003). Creating multiple water temperatures in hydronic heating systems. PM Engineer. Retrieved from https://digital.bnpengage.com/
Show 27 more sourcesHide additional sources
Burr, W. (2026). Guide to the Canadian Electrical Code, Part 1, 26th edition – A road map: Section 62. Electrical Industry News Week. Retrieved from https://electricalindustry.ca/
Electrical Safety Authority. (n.d.). Flash 22-20-FL: Electric in-floor heating system installations. Retrieved from https://esasafe.com/
Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro. (2026). Current rates. Retrieved from https://nlhydro.com/
Utilities Consumer Advocate, Government of Alberta. (2026). Default rates. Retrieved from https://ucahelps.alberta.ca/
British Columbia Utilities Commission. (2026). Residential energy rates. Retrieved from https://www.bcuc.com/
Electro-Federation Canada. (2026). Codes and standards: Canadian Electrical Code, Part 1, adoption by province. Retrieved from https://www.electrofed.com/