Most hires go fine. These are the signals that one will not.
No credential, or a vague one. In provinces that certify or register the work, "we've been doing this for years" is not an answer to "what is your certificate number?"
No disposal destination. Septage has to go to an approved site. A hauler who cannot say where yours will go is a risk you carry.
Pumping through one lid only. Especially on a two-compartment tank, this leaves solids behind and is the most common way a pump-out underdelivers.
No measurements. If the operator does not measure the layers, the next interval is a guess.
An additive pitched as a substitute for pumping. The Ontario Onsite Wastewater Association says claims that additives eliminate the need to pump should be treated with skepticism, because tanks accumulate sand, grit and plastics that bacteria cannot digest, and independent studies indicate additives do not prevent sludge from building up. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency likewise does not recommend them.
A field diagnosis from the truck, with a replacement quote attached. Observations belong on the report. A replacement or major repair decision belongs with a qualified practitioner, after a proper assessment.
No written report. If nothing is written down, you paid for a service you cannot prove happened.
A septic pump-out is one of several rural-property checks where the paperwork matters as much as the work.
Our overview of what a home inspector actually checks helps you decide when a broader inspection is warranted.