The mix effect is stronger in smaller markets, because fewer sales mean each one carries more weight. CREA's board-level pages publish the benchmark and the average together, which makes the comparison easy to run.
Kingston, August 2026, on 239 sales: CREA's page for the Kingston and Area Real Estate Association shows a composite benchmark price of $550,100, up 0.2% from a year earlier, against an average price of $612,691, up 2.7%. The benchmark detail underneath is uneven: single-family unchanged at $574,500, townhouse and row units up 1.4% at $408,100, and apartments down 6.4% at $350,100. The year-to-date average, which pools eight months of sales, was up only 0.1%.
Sault Ste. Marie, the same month, on 145 sales: the benchmark was $318,300, up 0.2%. The average was $347,370, up 7.9%. The year-to-date average was $328,224, down 2.9%. Three price signals, three directions, one market. The benchmark is the only one of the three that holds the home constant.
Greater Toronto shows the large-market version. In August 2026 the Toronto board's composite index was down 4.5% year over year while its average price, $993,410, was down 2.7%. Same direction, different size.
Two practical points follow. A year-to-date average is steadier than a single month's, because pooling sales dilutes the mix effect. And in a small market, the monthly average deserves the least weight of any published price figure.
Board-level benchmarks also feed Homeowner.ca's regional reporting, including the piece on the GTA benchmark slipping 6.7% as May listings dropped.