The Supply Argument, Reframed
The tempting GTA narrative goes like this: completions are weak, Toronto's starts trend is flat, so less new supply explains why resale prices have stopped falling. The August data does not support the first half of that sentence for Toronto. Completions there rose. What the data does support is a slower, structural version of the argument.
Resale prices in the GTA have levelled off month to month. The Toronto Regional Real Estate Board's August market report shows the MLS Home Price Index composite benchmark was 4.5% lower than a year earlier but essentially flat against July on a seasonally adjusted basis. Sales of 5,057 homes were down 2.1% year over year, and new listings of 12,075 were down 14.1%. TRREB said the number of homes available for sale was "down noticeably" from last year and that sales were arguably limited by less choice in some neighbourhoods.
That is a resale-supply story first. Construction data adds a longer-range layer: CMHC's September 10 housing supply release says that in Toronto the supply gap is "increasingly concentrated in the ownership market, where new construction remains exceptionally weak." Much of what is being built in major markets is purpose-built rental. For an owner selling a detached or semi-detached home, that means the new-build supply competing for the same ownership buyer is thinner than the raw completions count implies.
None of this demonstrates that weak construction caused prices to stabilize. Price stability has several drivers, and the benchmark and average price measure different things. The fair reading is narrower: in the GTA, the new-ownership pipeline is weak, resale listings are down year over year, and prices have stopped sliding month to month. Those facts point in the same direction without proving a cause.
Our coverage of GTA home sales jumping 9.4% in June tracks how that tightening developed earlier in the summer.