Here is the finding most likely to change how you think about renewal timing. Prima models the main CPI shelter components separately rather than as one blended shelter price, and once you separate them, they move in opposite directions after a rate increase. Mortgage interest costs depend on the rates applying to outstanding debt and on principal carried forward from past house prices, so market rates pass through gradually as mortgages renew. Other owned-accommodation costs track construction and renovation. Rent reflects demand against a slow-moving rental stock.
In the same 100-basis-point simulation, as set out in the Bank's overview of the model, mortgage interest cost inflation rises 0.105 percentage points in the first quarter and peaks at 0.22 percentage points in the fourth. Owned-accommodation inflation excluding mortgage interest moves the other way, down 0.01 percentage points at first and 0.125 percentage points by the fourth quarter, reaching its trough around 0.215 percentage points below control in the ninth. Total shelter inflation therefore peaks early — 0.135 percentage points above control in the second quarter — and only turns negative in the fifth.
Mortgage Interest Rises First; Everything Else Eases Later
Rent is slower still. Population-related rental demand stays firm, the rental stock adjusts only as construction completes, and rents on existing leases change at lease turnover rather than on announcement day. In the simulation, the rented-accommodation response sits essentially flat for the first several quarters before drifting negative much later.
Stack those timelines and the asymmetry is unmistakable. Higher rates reach a renewing borrower's payment within quarters. The offsetting relief — softer construction costs, cooler house prices, eventually easing rents — arrives over years. For anyone choosing between renewal strategies, that sequencing is the substantive point: a reset that lands early in a tightening cycle collects the full cost increase and none of the compensating disinflation.
The rate environment that renewing borrowers are walking into is covered in Bank of Canada Holds at 2.25% for Seventh Straight Meeting as Long Bond Yields Push Fixed Rates Up.